The Yellowstone universe is shifting its gaze beyond John Dutton, as the upcoming Beth and Rip spinoff stakes its claim on a new generation. With Kevin Costner’s towering presence unlikely to reprise, casting buzz reveals a search for a Costner-like figure to anchor Kelly Reilly and Cole Hauser’s return as Beth and Rip.
Yet, the real heir apparent isn’t a new face but a familiar one: Finn Little’s Carter. Deadline confirms Carter will follow Beth and Rip to their new life on a Montana ranch, cementing his role as their surrogate son and potentially the next Dutton patriarch in waiting. This development directly ties into Yellowstone season 5’s finale, where Carter’s relocation with the couple signaled his permanent place within their sphere.
Taylor Sheridan’s storytelling blueprint relies on seasoned elders mentoring younger blood, as evidenced by Costner’s John Dutton and Harrison Ford’s Jacob Dutton in 1923. And, as Carter matures alongside Beth and Rip (Cole Hauser), the spinoff has fertile ground to explore the evolution of Dutton family power and values.
Finn Little’s Return: The Keystone in Beth and Rip’s Yellowstone Spinoff
Bringing Finn Little back as Carter confirms the new series will build directly on the relationships and plot threads left dangling in Yellowstone’s closing chapter. Carter’s migration with Beth (Kelly Reilly) and Rip to the Dillon ranch was a cornerstone for the narrative architecture of the spinoff. His role shifts from supporting character to pivotal, expanding storytelling possibilities as the youthful surrogate son transitions into a young man potentially destined to uphold the Dutton legacy.
Beth & Rip Yellowstone Spinoff: Will Carter Be Beth Dutton’s Shot at Redemption?
Carter’s arc has always mirrored the show’s central theme of inheritance, both of land and legacy. His admiration for John Dutton, verbalized as “I want to be him” (in Yellowstone season 4, episode 6), places him firmly in the mold of a successor.
From his introduction, Carter symbolized the struggle to rise above personal tragedy and find belonging. This evolution makes him a natural candidate to carry forward the Yellowstone mantle, especially since his loyalty and ambition mirror John Dutton’s own grit.
Taylor Sheridan’s pattern of generational transition, from Kevin Costner’s John to younger Duttons, finds a new expression here. That being said, the presence of Carter signals a deliberate passing of the torch.
Our Thoughts on Carter Being the Unquestionable Heir to John Dutton’s Throne
Carter’s positioning as John Dutton’s rightful successor in Beth and Rip’s spinoff seems to be a calculated move grounded in character development and franchise continuity. Unlike Tate, whose wavering commitment to ranch life left fans uncertain of his future, Carter has demonstrated firm dedication since his first appearance. His formative interactions with John Dutton offered a close-up education in leadership and resilience, skills he now hones under Beth and Rip’s guardianship.
Finn Little’s growth alongside his character infuses Carter with a subtle charm and gravitas that resonate with viewers. As Yellowstone’s sprawling saga ventures into new territory, Carter embodies both continuity and evolution: he doesn’t replace John but rather embodies what John represented, refined for a new era.
